Machine Gun Preacher

2011-10-08

By Richard von Busack

The glib way to sum up Machine Gun Preacher is that it’s a case of too much preaching and not enough machine guns. Marc Forster’s film—as tone-deaf to American culture as his art-house hit Monster’s Ball---has an interesting real-life story. Sam Childers (Gerard Butler) was a born-again former biker and petty criminal from Pennsylvania who decided to give up everything to help war refugees in Sudan. In Africa, he turned into a machine-gun carrying guerilla to protect the orphans in his care from raiders…even though (as this movie claims, anyway) this obsession endangered his marriage.
Jason Keller’s script reduces this unusual story to pure Jack Chick comic; Foster’s action sequences are only slightly more legible than the edited to shreds stuff he did in Quantum of Solace. Glimmerings of the film’s potential are visible from Michelle Monaghan, as his absurdly loyal wife. But Machine Gun Preacher is stolen by Michael Shannon, previewing his startlingly fine acting in Take Shelter:
Shannon plays Sam’s best bud Donnie, loose in tongue, wild in eyeballs and twitchy even in recovery. Shannon demonstrates the art of mushmouthing dialogue that isn’t worth enunciating. (Though we don’t see his dental work, he seems like he’s trying to sound like he’s missing a lot of teeth.) Sam hits bottom during a wild ride with Donnie who is trying to shoot up a spoonful of something or other, even as he’s driving through a winter night.
Compared to this diabolical inspiration, the lead Butler’s wrestling with his God isn’t as interesting—he’s monotonous, from getting dunked at a brick church, to rounding up orphans. And the kids themselves are so indistinguishable to Forster’s camera that one of them has to be scar-faced and mute so we can tell him from the rest. The film doesn’t seriously consider the Christian duty to turn the other cheek, and it doesn’t fulfill its duty to its grindhouse title, either.